the artist (1824-1906);
to the estate of the artist, 1906;
sold to Charles M. Kurtz (1855–1909), Buffalo, in the estate sale of Eastman Johnson (American Art Galleries, New York, February 26-27, 1907, no. 98), February 27, 1907;
to the estate of Charles M. Kurtz, Buffalo, 1909;
to his widow, Julia Stephenson Kurtz (1861-1931), Buffalo, 1909;
to the estate of Julia Stephenson Kurtz, Buffalo, 1931;
to her daughter, Isabella S. Kurtz (1901-1991), Buffalo, 1931;
donated by Isabella S. Kurtz to the Albright-Knox Art Gallery, December 17, 1982